# Mystery Subscriptions

> Immersive mystery experiences delivered through the mail

**Source:** [Letter Clubs](https://letterclubs.com) | **Category page:** https://letterclubs.com/category/mystery
**14 clubs** in this category

---

### [Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://letterclubs.com/club/dear-holmes)

*Solve a Victorian mystery one letter at a time* — 4.8/5 (189 reviews)

A monthly mystery subscription where you receive in-character letters from Sherlock Holmes, Watson, and Victorian clients - and must piece together the solution yourself.

**Details:**  | From $14/mo | Weekly letters, monthly mysteries | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://www.dearholmes.com)

---

### [Mail Order Mystery](https://letterclubs.com/club/mail-order-mystery)

*A whodunit delivered to your door* — 4.6/5 (98 reviews)

Each month brings a new mystery case: physical evidence, suspect profiles, and a puzzle you must solve before the next installment arrives.

**Details:**  | $29\.99/mo | Monthly | Ships: US & Canada

[Visit Mail Order Mystery](https://www.mailordermystery.com)

---

### [Mythbridger](https://letterclubs.com/club/mythbridger)

*Fantasy letters from a world of myth and magic* — 4.8/5 (112 reviews)

A fantasy fiction subscription where you receive handcrafted letters from characters in an original mythological world, with lore, maps, and collectible artifacts.

**Details:**  | $25/mo | Monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Mythbridger](https://www.mythbridger.com)

---

### [Epistolary](https://letterclubs.com/club/epistolary)

*Immersive stories told entirely through letters and artifacts*

Epistolary delivers immersive stories through physical letters and artifacts mailed over 12 months. Each story is designed to draw readers into a unique world - from cozy mysteries to romance and horror - told exclusively through the mail.

**Details:**  | From $8\.25/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Epistolary](https://epistolary.com/)

---

### [Storyville Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/storyville-letters)

*Original epistolary fiction, dispatched by post\. Twice a month\. For a full year\. Written by a real human\.*

Most letter subscriptions give you a puzzle to solve. Storyville gives you a story you cannot put down. We apologize in advance for the sleep you are about to lose.
Twenty-four real letters over twelve months. Written by a real human author since 2023. Not AI. Not templated. Not something you scroll past. Real writing. Real mail. Real magic. Do not say we did not warn you.

**Details:**  | From $11\.41/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Storyville Letters](https://storyvilleletters.com/)

---

### [Tin Box Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/tin-box-letters)

*A historical romantic adventure told through letters, twice a month*

Tin Box Letters is a year-long subscription to a story told through 24 letters. Each envelope is a chapter filled with letters and diary entries from the characters, newspaper articles, postcards and more. Current story: Finch and Hawk: The Klondike Letters.

**Details:**  | From $14\.99/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Tin Box Letters](https://tinboxletters.com/)

---

### [Letters by Lanternlight](https://letterclubs.com/club/letters-by-lanternlight)

*Handwritten cozy mystery stories delivered to your mailbox*

Letters by Lanternlight delivers immersive, handwritten cozy mystery stories through the mail. Each story unfolds through letters from protagonist Lydia Bellweather, complete with tactile clues and keepsakes for a screen-free reading experience.

**Details:**  | From $59\.99 | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Letters by Lanternlight](https://lettersbylanternlight.com/)

---

### [The Mossheart Mail Club](https://letterclubs.com/club/mossheart-mail-club)

*Whimsical watercolor art, cozy fantasy stories, and surprises by post*

A monthly feel-good letter filled with whimsical watercolor art, cozy fantasy stories, audiobooks and thoughtful surprises from the world of Mossheart. Each mailing includes a 5x7 art print, gold foiled affirmation card, handmade sticker, and a mystery item.

**Details:**  | From $11\.42/mo | Monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit The Mossheart Mail Club](https://worldofmossheart.com/products/the-mossheart-mail-club)

---

### [The Three Hands Mail Club](https://letterclubs.com/club/three-hands-mail-club)

*Unravel a captivating mystery set in a quaint seaside town*

Join Maran Smith's journey to uncover secrets of poisonings, missing persons, and supernatural entities in Port Angles, WA. Each month, receive a letter detailing her adventures, accompanied by cards, stickers, and hand-painted artwork.

**Details:**  | $10\.00/month | Monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit The Three Hands Mail Club](https://three-hands-mail-club.myshopify.com/products/peregrines-tea-shop-collection)

---

### [Moonlightpostco](https://letterclubs.com/club/moonlightpostco-LQgK4xAd)

* Where letter open another world*

Moonlight Mail is a fantasy mystery snail mail experience that invites you into a world of magic, lore, and secrets waiting to be discovered.

**Details:**  | $10\.00 | monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Moonlightpostco](https://ko-fi.com/moonlightpostco)

---

### [The Silver Key Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/the-silver-key-letters-sFgtxlkW)

*Where forgotten places, magical object and real monthly letters become a cosy fantasy story\.*

Step into the world of The Silver Key through a monthly chapter delivered as real mail. Each letter combines cosy fantasy storytelling with real forgotten places, illustrated paper goods, story-inspired surprises and trinkets, and seasonal recipies, creating an immersive mystery you can read, collect and experience.

**Details:**  | € 14,95 | Monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit The Silver Key Letters](https://thesilverkeyletters.com/)

---

### [Curious Cabinet Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/curious-cabinet-letters-Jrrpu6d3)

*Curiosity cases for minds that need to know why\.*

Every month, open a new curiosity case and follow the story wherever it leads. From strange inventions to everyday mysteries, each letter is a little rabbit hole designed to make you wonder, question, and see the world a bit differently.

**Details:**  | $12/mo | Monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Curious Cabinet Letters](https://curiouscabinetletters.com/)

---

### [The Perplex Post](https://letterclubs.com/club/the-perplex-post-fCCm5nci)

*A short mystery story through your letterbox\. *

A short mystery story delivered every other month written by bestselling mystery and thriller author V. J. Randle. Each "post" features a special illustrative flourish and is standalone. So, magnifying glasses at the ready! 

**Details:**  | £15/annum | Bimonthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit The Perplex Post](https://www.victoriarandleauthor.com/perplexpost)

---

### [The Unmarked Society](https://letterclubs.com/club/the-unmarked-society-aGSmv0gL)

*A serialized mystery delivered by mail, with fictional evidence, art prints, character cards, and puzzles\.*

The Unmarked Society is your new mystery obsession.

The first story, Shadows of Seattle, takes place in 2007 and follows a missing girl, her determined best friend, and a detective fighting to rebuild her reputation.

Twice a month, envelopes arrive in your mailbox, packed with fictional evidence, illustrated artwork, stickers, and collectible paper goods inspired by the story. From case files and character cards to photographs and puzzles, each delivery brings the mystery to life as it unfolds.

Follow the clues. Meet the suspects. Discover the story, one envelope at a time.

**Details:**  | $15\-$25 | Twice a month | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit The Unmarked Society](https://theunmarkedsociety.com/)

---
