# Mystery Subscriptions

> Immersive mystery experiences delivered through the mail

**Source:** [Letter Clubs](https://letterclubs.com) | **Category page:** https://letterclubs.com/category/mystery
**9 clubs** in this category

---

### [Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://letterclubs.com/club/dear-holmes)

*Solve a Victorian mystery one letter at a time* — 4.8/5 (189 reviews)

A monthly mystery subscription where you receive in-character letters from Sherlock Holmes, Watson, and Victorian clients - and must piece together the solution yourself.

**Details:**  | From $14/mo | Weekly letters, monthly mysteries | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://www.dearholmes.com)

---

### [Mail Order Mystery](https://letterclubs.com/club/mail-order-mystery)

*A whodunit delivered to your door* — 4.6/5 (98 reviews)

Each month brings a new mystery case: physical evidence, suspect profiles, and a puzzle you must solve before the next installment arrives.

**Details:**  | $29\.99/mo | Monthly | Ships: US & Canada

[Visit Mail Order Mystery](https://www.mailordermystery.com)

---

### [Mythbridger](https://letterclubs.com/club/mythbridger)

*Fantasy letters from a world of myth and magic* — 4.8/5 (112 reviews)

A fantasy fiction subscription where you receive handcrafted letters from characters in an original mythological world, with lore, maps, and collectible artifacts.

**Details:**  | $25/mo | Monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Mythbridger](https://www.mythbridger.com)

---

### [Epistolary](https://letterclubs.com/club/epistolary)

*Immersive stories told entirely through letters and artifacts*

Epistolary delivers immersive stories through physical letters and artifacts mailed over 12 months. Each story is designed to draw readers into a unique world - from cozy mysteries to romance and horror - told exclusively through the mail.

**Details:**  | From $8\.25/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Epistolary](https://epistolary.com/)

---

### [Storyville Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/storyville-letters)

*Original epistolary fiction, dispatched by post\. Twice a month\. For a full year\. Written by a real human\.*

Most letter subscriptions give you a puzzle to solve. Storyville gives you a story you cannot put down. We apologize in advance for the sleep you are about to lose.
Twenty-four real letters over twelve months. Written by a real human author since 2023. Not AI. Not templated. Not something you scroll past. Real writing. Real mail. Real magic. Do not say we did not warn you.

**Details:**  | From $11\.41/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit Storyville Letters](https://storyvilleletters.com/)

---

### [Tin Box Letters](https://letterclubs.com/club/tin-box-letters)

*A historical romantic adventure told through letters, twice a month*

Tin Box Letters is a year-long subscription to a story told through 24 letters. Each envelope is a chapter filled with letters and diary entries from the characters, newspaper articles, postcards and more. Current story: Finch and Hawk: The Klondike Letters.

**Details:**  | From $14\.99/mo | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Tin Box Letters](https://tinboxletters.com/)

---

### [Letters by Lanternlight](https://letterclubs.com/club/letters-by-lanternlight)

*Handwritten cozy mystery stories delivered to your mailbox*

Letters by Lanternlight delivers immersive, handwritten cozy mystery stories through the mail. Each story unfolds through letters from protagonist Lydia Bellweather, complete with tactile clues and keepsakes for a screen-free reading experience.

**Details:**  | From $59\.99 | Twice monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit Letters by Lanternlight](https://lettersbylanternlight.com/)

---

### [The Mossheart Mail Club](https://letterclubs.com/club/mossheart-mail-club)

*Whimsical watercolor art, cozy fantasy stories, and surprises by post*

A monthly feel-good letter filled with whimsical watercolor art, cozy fantasy stories, audiobooks and thoughtful surprises from the world of Mossheart. Each mailing includes a 5x7 art print, gold foiled affirmation card, handmade sticker, and a mystery item.

**Details:**  | From $11\.42/mo | Monthly | Ships: Worldwide

[Visit The Mossheart Mail Club](https://worldofmossheart.com/products/the-mossheart-mail-club)

---

### [The Three Hands Mail Club](https://letterclubs.com/club/three-hands-mail-club)

*Unravel a captivating mystery set in a quaint seaside town*

Join Maran Smith's journey to uncover secrets of poisonings, missing persons, and supernatural entities in Port Angles, WA. Each month, receive a letter detailing her adventures, accompanied by cards, stickers, and hand-painted artwork.

**Details:**  | $10\.00/month | Monthly | Ships: US only

[Visit The Three Hands Mail Club](https://three-hands-mail-club.myshopify.com/products/peregrines-tea-shop-collection)

---