# Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail vs Mail Order Mystery

> Side-by-side comparison of two snail mail subscription clubs.

**Source:** [Letter Clubs](https://letterclubs.com/compare/dear-holmes-vs-mail-order-mystery)

## Quick Comparison

| Feature | Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail | Mail Order Mystery |
|---------|-----------------------------|--------------------|
| **Price** | From $14/mo | $29\.99/mo |
| **Frequency** | Weekly letters, monthly mysteries | Monthly |
| **Ships** | Worldwide | US & Canada |
| **Rating** | 4.8/5 | 4.6/5 |

---

## Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail
*Solve a Victorian mystery one letter at a time*

![Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0747/4466/0290/products/FileJan19_110227AM.png?width=800)

| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Price** | From $14/mo — 3, 6, and 12\-month plans available\. Does not auto\-renew\. |
| **Frequency** | Weekly letters, monthly mysteries |
| **Ships** | Worldwide |
| **Country** | US |
| **Rating** | 4.8/5 (189 reviews) |

A monthly mystery subscription where you receive in-character letters from Sherlock Holmes, Watson, and Victorian clients - and must piece together the solution yourself.

Dear Holmes is a narrative mystery subscription that unfolds entirely through the mail. Each month, subscribers receive letters from Sherlock Holmes, Dr. Watson, and their latest Victorian client, along with physical clue packets and handcrafted evidence. Cases are written by modern Sherlock Holmes authors and edited by Dear Holmes mystery editors in partnership with MX Publishing, the world's largest specialist Holmes publisher. A companion podcast provides audiobook-quality narrations of each case. The experience is deeply immersive and rewards careful readers.

**Tags:** `mystery`, `weekly`, `letters`, `interactive`, `fiction`, `puzzle`, `sherlock-holmes`

**Social:** [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/my_dear_holmes) | [Twitter/X](https://twitter.com/my_dear_holmes)

**[Visit Dear Holmes Mysterious Mail](https://www.dearholmes.com)**
[Read reviews](https://letterclubs.com/club/dear-holmes/reviews)

---

## Mail Order Mystery
*A whodunit delivered to your door*

![Mail Order Mystery](https://www.mailordermystery.com/cdn/shop/t/20/assets/home_slide_1.jpg?v=26590866383826360181771367511)

| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Price** | $29\.99/mo |
| **Frequency** | Monthly |
| **Ships** | US & Canada |
| **Country** | US |
| **Rating** | 4.6/5 (98 reviews) |

Each month brings a new mystery case: physical evidence, suspect profiles, and a puzzle you must solve before the next installment arrives.

Mail Order Mystery delivers a complete mystery experience through the post. Subscribers receive a dossier of physical evidence - photographs, handwritten notes, newspaper clippings, and suspect files - and must work out who committed the crime. Each case is self-contained, making it easy to start at any time. The production quality is high, and the puzzles strike a satisfying balance between accessible and genuinely challenging.

**Tags:** `mystery`, `puzzle`, `monthly`, `letters`, `interactive`

**[Visit Mail Order Mystery](https://www.mailordermystery.com)**
[Read reviews](https://letterclubs.com/club/mail-order-mystery/reviews)