Rating: 4.6/5 (98 reviews)

Each month brings a new mystery case: physical evidence, suspect profiles, and a puzzle you must solve before the next installment arrives.

Mail Order Mystery delivers a complete mystery experience through the post. Subscribers receive a dossier of physical evidence - photographs, handwritten notes, newspaper clippings, and suspect files - and must work out who committed the crime. Each case is self-contained, making it easy to start at any time. The production quality is high, and the puzzles strike a satisfying balance between accessible and genuinely challenging.

mystery puzzle monthly letters interactive

Join Maran Smith's journey to uncover secrets of poisonings, missing persons, and supernatural entities in Port Angles, WA. Each month, receive a letter detailing her adventures, accompanied by cards, stickers, and hand-painted artwork.

Subscribers delve into an unfolding narrative where old-world magic meets small-town intrigue. Every monthly delivery includes a multi-page letter advancing the story, along with a greeting card and a postcard. Additional curated items like stickers, in-story art, newspaper bits, or even recipes are included to enhance the immersive experience. All artwork features hand-painted elements directly inspired by the story, some with hidden depths.

monthly storytelling mystery supernatural stickers art-print handwritten-style pen-pal-option